Newthinking Puppy Heartbeat Stuffed Toy - Pet Anxiety Relief and Calming Aid, Soft Plush Sleeping Buddy Behavioral Aid Dog Toy, with Heartbeat for

The Newthinking Puppy Heartbeat Stuffed Toy has received mixed reviews from customers. Some customers have found great success with the product, stating that it effectively calmed their puppies and helped them sleep through the night. However, others have expressed disappointment, citing issues such as the heartbeat stopping after a short time or the toy being too loud and strong. One customer mentioned that the toy worked well initially but their puppy eventually wanted to chew it to pieces. Another customer attempted to dampen the volume and vibration of the heartbeat but found no success. Additionally, some customers felt that the toy was a waste of money as the batteries did not last long and it made no difference in soothing their puppies. There were also complaints about the design, with customers wishing for a toy that could be easily switched on and off without having to open it up. Some customers also mentioned that the toy was not soft, with their puppies not liking it. Overall, while some customers have had success with the Newthinking Puppy Heartbeat Stuffed Toy, there are several issues that need to be addressed, such as the durability and the volume of the heartbeat.